Public Opinion And Daca: What Do The Polls Say
AEIdeas
President Trump last Tuesday announced his decision to rescind the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program put in place by President Obamas executive order in 2012. Polls show public opinion at odds with Trumps decision.
Demonstrators protest in front of the White House after the Trump administration scrapped the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals , a program that protects from deportation almost 800,000 young men and women who were brought into the US illegally as children. REUTERS/Kevin Lamarque
In a YouGov/Economist poll taken before Trumps announcement, a solid plurality of Americans said they wanted him to keep DACA, while 29% wanted the President to end it. Democrats and independents were in favor of keeping the program. Only 30% of Republicans were, while 49% said it should be ended. After the announcement, 55% of Americans in a HuffPost/YouGov survey said they thought Trump made the wrong decision, with 88% of Democrats and 53% of independents giving that response. 83% of Republicans thought the president made the right decision.
See also: Hillary, What Happened? A Retrospective
In all recent surveys, majorities of Democrats were supportive of DACA and allowing Dreamers to stay. Republicans responses varied, with most surveys showing them either opposed or divided about DACA.
Texas Republicans Are Leading The Charge To End Daca And Block Legislative Fix For Dreamers
On 10th Anniversary of DACA, TX GOP Silent on TX Dreamers Loud on Invasion and Deportation
Washington, DC This weeks ten year anniversary of the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals programs implementation is an opportunity to reflect on the success and importance of this life-changing program. Its also a moment of mounting frustration, given the tenuous future facing Dreamers due to Republicans continued legal challenges to DACA and the GOPs legislative obstruction to a permanent solution.
Texas Republicans are leading the charge against DACA and Dreamers. Because of this, the full slate of Texas GOP elected officials and candidates on the ballot should define their position toward DACA and a legislative solution for Dreamers. Vague statements of support are insufficient when the Texas GOP is leading the charge to make Dreamers with DACA deportable.
How Texas Republicans are leading charge against DACA and permanent fix for Dreamers.
This despite the reality that Texas voters overwhelmingly support DACA and Dreamers. A new poll from the Dallas Morning News/UT Tyler shows that while public sentiment on border security questions is largely divided along partisan lines, protections for Dreamers is broadly popular among Texas voters. The poll asked, Do you support or oppose granting permanent legal status to immigrants who came to the U.S. illegally when they were children?
According to Mario Carrillo, Texas-based Campaigns Director for Americas Voice:
Who Is For And Against Ending Daca
The Trump administration has argued that President Obama did not have the authority to create the Daca programme through executive order, though Mr Trump has appeared sympathetic to the Dreamers’ plight.
Mr Trump successfully ordered DHS to stop accepting new applications in 2017, but his second order to end renewals for Daca recipients was blocked last January and is the one up before the Supreme Court.
In 2018, the then-DHS Secretary Kirstjen Nielsen wrote that the programme should end as it is “critically important for DHS to project a message that leaves no doubt regarding the clear, consistent, and transparent enforcement of the immigration laws against all classes and categories of aliens”.
The White House has tried to negotiate with lawmakers on a plan to allow the undocumented immigrants a path towards citizenship in exchange for funding for Mr Trump’s border wall with Mexico to no avail.
Two out of three US adults back Daca, according to surveys conducted last year.
What is temporary protected status – and why is El Salvador losing it?
You May Like: Did Any Republicans Vote To Impeach
Democratic View On Immigration
Democrats strive for immigration reform that focuses on the humanity of immigrants, documented or undocumented. While the party platform does include border security, it also seeks to put the time, effort and cost of enforcement into a focus on criminals, rather than families.
The Democratic platform alleges there is bigotry inherent in President Trumps immigration actions and fear incited by President Trump, putting an emphasis on stopping his administrations practice of separating families.
Democrats are fighting for every immigrant who feels threatened by Donald Trumps election. We will not stand by and watch families be torn apart Democrats in Congress and in states and cities across the country are already standing up to Trumps hatred and bigotry to defend their immigrant neighbors.
The bottom line from Democrats: We honor our fundamental values by treating all people who come to the United States with dignity and respect, and we always seek to embrace not to attack immigrants.
What Is Daca And The Arguments For And Against It
DACA stands for Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals. It is a form of administrative relief from the threat of deportation for being an illegal immigrant in the United States. The purpose of the program is to protect the children who were brought into the U.S. by their parents without permission.
DACA gives undocumented workers two specific benefits. It provides them with a 2-year work permit, and it offers protection against deportation.
Specific requirements must be met by individuals to get into this program. You must be under 31 years of age as of June 15, 2012. You had to come to the United States before your 16th birthday. There are also residency requirements, educational achievements, and personal conduct stipulations to meet.
What Are the Arguments for DACA?
1. It can increase wages in a community.
When there are more immigrants active in the U.S. economy, then more jobs get created overall. That means the wages of everyone will go up because there is more competition for the best jobs available. This process could add up to $14 billion more to the national economy, along with $4 billion in new tax revenues.
2. It adds diversity to the economy.
When people come from different backgrounds and cultures, their diversity adds strength to communities. It is a trait that allows companies to be more competitive and innovative.
3. It allows people to serve in the military.
What Are the Arguments Against DACA?
1. It protects people who broke the law.
Read Also: Michael Bloomberg Is A Republican
Daca Fix Gets Some Republican Support
On Wednesday, the former Secretary of Defense Robert Gates, authored an Op-ed Opinion in the New York Times that ending DACA will undermine national security efforts. Gates pointed out that more than 800 Dreamers are currently serving in the armed forces. He highlighted that between 2006 through 2011 more than 45,000 immigrants served in the military and later became citizens. Gates went on to say:
As we observe Veterans Day, we remember with reverence the extraordinary debt we owe to those who have served in uniform and sacrificed, even unto death, for their fellow Americans. This includes the more than 109,000 immigrants who, since Sept. 11, 2001They have been part of a rarefied group: the 1 percent of Americans native-born, naturalized and undocumented immigrants alike who constitute our military. who said he felt humbled by their sense of duty, by their willingness to risk life and limb for a country they yearned to call their own.
The Supreme Court May Let Trump End Daca Heres What The Public Thinks About It
Polls show the program to protect young undocumented immigrants from deportation is broadly popular. Democratic organizers see an opportunity to mobilize voters if it is ended.
-
Send any friend a story
As a subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to give each month. Anyone can read what you share.
Give this article
Welcome to Poll Watch, our weekly look at polling data and survey research on the candidates, voters and issues that will shape the 2020 election.
It increasingly looks like the Supreme Courts conservative majority will allow the Trump administration to end the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, or DACA, according to close observers of the court.
Legal arguments aside, polls show that DACA which has shielded from deportation roughly 700,000 undocumented immigrants who were brought to the United States as children enjoys overwhelming popular support. Allowing it to end would put the court out of step with trends in national public opinion, which has recently become more sympathetic to immigration than at any point in recorded history.
But the voters who pay the closest attention to immigration tend to be Republicans, and they hold much more conservative views on this issue. Just before the 2018 midterm elections, a Pew survey found that Republican voters were four times as likely as Democratic voters to say illegal immigration was a very big problem: 75 percent of Republicans said it was, compared to 19 percent of Democrats.
Recommended Reading: Tv Channel For Patriots Game Tonight
Trump Likely To End Program Protecting Young Undocumented Immigrants
“It is right for there to be consequences for those who intentionally entered this country illegally,” Sen. James Lankford, R-Okla., said in a statement Monday. “However, we as Americans do not hold children legally accountable for the actions of their parents.”
Spoke w/@wsvn: #DACA was a temporary measure that Congress must now make a permanent law. 6 months is ample time for us to act!
Ileana Ros-Lehtinen
The president is leaning toward ending DACA, but with a six-month delay, possibly giving Congress a window to revamp the program, two sources told NBC News. The decision, which was first reported by Politico and is likely to come Tuesday, is not final until it is announced, the sources added.
Republican lawmakers, including some of Trump’s closest allies in Congress, have publicly spoken out against the decision they say would unjustly punish those who did nothing wrong.
Related: Immigrant Advocates for DACA Keep Up the Pressure on Trump
“I don’t think he should do that. I believe that this is something Congress has to fix,” House Speaker Paul Ryan said during a radio interview last week.
Republican Sen. Orrin Hatch of Utah, one of Trump’s top conservative defenders in the Senate, also released a statement last week advocating for DACA’s survival.
Senator Charles Grassley On Daca
Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Senator Charles Grassley has been a supporter of DACA for awhile, and this support largely comes from his belief in the e-Verify system. Mr. Grassley has said that all employers should be required to use the E-verify system in order to check on a potential employees working eligibility, for a system like this would make deportation of criminals easier and it would as well speed up deportation of asylum seekers who are unable to support their claims.
Don’t Miss: New England Patriots Football Jersey
Republicans Want A Daca Fix But Not Without Democratic Concessions
WASHINGTON Lawmakers on Capitol Hill broadly agreed on Tuesday that something should be done about young undocumented immigrants who came to the U.S. as children and who will eventually lose deportation protections if Congress does not step in to help them.
But Republicans are already placing conditions on their support that could kill the effort entirely. They are willing to vote for protecting so-called Dreamers but not without getting something in exchange for it.
Hopefully there will be some give and take and we can accomplish something, Sen. Ron Johnson said, suggesting Democrats could support efforts to boost border security.
President Donald Trump announced on Tuesday that his administration rescinded the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, with enforcement to begin in six months. That time period gives Congress time to pass its own measures to allow undocumented young people to stay in the country, something that a majority of Americans support.
Most Republicans in Congress have previously opposed such measures. A majority of them voted against past versions of the Dream Act, a stand-alone bill that would provide legal status to young undocumented immigrants who came to the U.S. as children. Some GOP senators voted for a comprehensive immigration reform bill that included measures for Dreamers in 2013, but also would have increased border security and included other enforcement measures.
The End Of Daca Leading Republicans Split On Repeal Of ‘dreamer’ Rule
“I’ve urged the president not to rescind DACA, an action that would further complicate a system in serious need of a permanent, legislative solution,” Hatch said. “Like the president, I’ve long advocated for tougher enforcement of our existing immigration laws. But we also need a workable, permanent solution for individuals who entered our country unlawfully as children through no fault of their own.”
Others in the GOP, including frequent Trump critic Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., expressed support for Trump’s measure, which he considers necessary to undoing an executive action by President Barack Obama he viewed as overreaching. But he still believes in a congressional fix.
“If President Trump makes this decision we will work to find a legislative solution to their dilemma,” Graham said in a statement Monday.
Immigration hardliner Steve King, however, is pushing for an immediate end to DACA. He tweeted that the six-month delay is “Republican suicide,” giving the GOP a chance to push what he called “amnesty.”
Ending DACA now gives chance 2 restore Rule of Law. Delaying so R Leadership can push Amnesty is Republican suicide.
Steve King
Any announced change to DACA on Tuesday would coincide with Republican officials in 10 states, led by Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, threatening to sue if Trump doesn’t end the program.
And Democratic Rep. Joaquin Castro of Texas asked on Twitter: “How does a five year old decide to break the law?”
Don’t Miss: How Many Republicans Need To Vote To Remove Trump
Republican Views On Daca
Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals has been a main subject of Republican political discussion since its inception in 2012. Although the DACA executive action, as well as the program it created, will in all likelihood be gone before the end of the Trump administration, the dilemma regarding what to do with the Dreamers, a specific class of young aliens DACA aimed to help, will for the time being go unsolved. Many Republicans are ardent opponents of DACA, but there are several high profile lawmakers in the Republican party who are not as opposed as others: these lawmakers are referred to commonly as immigration doves. DACA is a contentious issue within the Republican party, largely because it has to do with the subject of illegal immigration, which the vast amount of Republicans are fundamentally against. While most Republicans are opposed to the DACA executive order, there are some who believe the Dreamers should be allowed to stay because they contribute in many ways to American society. In the following sections, a brief history of the DACA executive order will be outlined, followed by a few brief summaries of where high profile Republicans stand on the issue of DACA.
What Have Republicans Said About Dreamers
Republicans are conflicted about Dreamers, the young immigrants who were brought here unlawfully as children. On the one hand, they oppose protections that they believe were enacted unconstitutionally without Congress, like the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program. On the other hand, Republicans favor the policy of protecting Dreamers on its merits.
In fact, a recent Morning Consult/Politico poll found three of four Trump voters support legal status for Dreamers. However, Republicans continue to debate about what the specifics of any proposal should look like. A Republican proposal called the Recognizing Americas Children Act, introduced by Rep. Carlos Curbelo in the House and soon to be introduced by Sen. Thom Tillis in the Senate, is gaining traction among Republicans as the conservative answer to Dreamers.
Many prominent Republicans have expressed sympathy for Dreamers which they could act on by supporting bills like the RAC Act. Here are some examples of what Republicans have had to say about Dreamers:
Don’t Miss: How Can I Watch Tonight’s Patriots Game
Senator Lindsey Graham On Daca
Senator Lindsey Graham of South Carolina has been a longtime supporter of the Dreamers, and his advocacy for DACA is in part what garnered the support of other Senate Republicans. How would you feel if you were one of those Dream Act kids knowing the only thing between you and certainty is Congress? Mr. Graham asked administration officials at the Senate hearing back in October of 2018.
As Republican Jeff Denham Pushes To Extend Daca How Do Voters Feel
This article is more than 4 years old.
California Republican congressman Jeff Denham is among a group of lawmakers bucking his own party and trying to force an immigration vote in the House of Representatives.
He’s supporting a bill that would extend the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program , which provides protections to immigrants who were brought into the country illegally as children.
With Democrats targeting his seat, Denham needs to appeal to moderates, without angering the Republican base. That could be tricky in a district that went for Democrat Hillary Clinton in the 2016 presidential election. The most recent data show 38.51 percent of voters registered as Democrats, 35.66 percent as Republicans and 20.51 percent as no party preference.
An unscientific sampling of voters found a wide range of feelings about the four-term incumbent congressman.
At a concert in Modesto’s 10th Street Plaza, Bill Heyden sat in a folding chair and watched as the band warmed up.
The property manager and one-time DJ already cast his mail-in ballot for Denham, and is generally supportive of tougher immigration policies. But he said kids shouldnt be punished for their parents decisions.
The parents are the ones who knew all along what they were doing and went along with the program,” Heyden said.
Go Jesse! Go, babe, go! Come on, babe,” she yelled as he ran by.
Denham is also facing pushback from people who used to support him.
You May Like: Patriotic Apparel Made In Usa
